Weather Newsday > News

Ice cream best bets on Long Island

Lauren DeVito poses for a portrait while eating

Jason Andrew

User rating:

Click to rate

Rockville Centre to Riverhead, Long Island is a hotbed of cold comfort: you're never more than a short drive from a terrific scoop. Here are 33 local parlors that make their own fresh, refreshing ice cream.

User rating 3

Baci Gelato Ice cream 591 Willis Ave. Williston Park Baci's wares come in about 100 flavors; two dozen or so are available on any ...
User rating 3

Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen $$ | Diner, Dessert, Ice cream 2391 Main St. Bridgehampton Little has changed at Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen since it opened in 1925. Locals and vacationing ...
User rating 4

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream $ | Ice cream, Soda fountain 75 Howells Rd. Bay Shore Coyle's, a Long Island staple since 1985, specializes in ice cream that is elaborate in ...
User rating 3

Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream $ | Ice cream, Dessert 509 Main St. Islip Coyle's makes a textbook ice-cream soda, and one of the most popular ice cream flavors ...
User rating 4

Five Pennies Creamery Ice cream 11 N. Park Ave. Rockville Centre In addition to fine ice cream, Five Pennies Creamery in Rockville Centre turns out Coney ...
User rating 3

Gooseberry Grove Ice cream 12 E. Main St. Oyster Bay If you're intent on ice cream: Gooseberry Grove, a nostalgic scoop of a place for ...
User rating 2

Henry's Confectionery $ | Ice cream, Luncheonette 8 Glen St. Glen Cove Henry's has been serving Glen Cove residents since 1929. For years, the store was owned ...
User rating 4

Herrell’s Ice Cream $ | Ice cream, Dessert 46L Gerard St. Huntington Rick and Cathy Meuser opened the doors less than two weeks ago to this Huntington ...
User rating 3

Hicksville Sweet Shop $ | Diner, Ice cream, Soda fountain, Dessert, Luncheonette 75 Broadway Hicksville Serving the Hicksville community for decades, this luncheonette offers a diner-style menu and a selection ...
User rating 3

Hildebrandt's $ | American, Burgers, Ice cream, Soda fountain, Dessert 84 Hillside Ave. Williston Park For the child in everyone, this nostalgic soda fountain-restaurant features house-made ice cream, classic burgers ...